Home > Leadership, Management > Fed up with feedback?

Fed up with feedback?

Feedback? what comes to mind when you hear that word? BOHICA? Bend Over Here it Comes Again!?  In many organisations feedback is just a moderately polite way of beating someone up, or a way of making you feel you have ‘done your job’ and ‘sorted someone out’ – as you SHOULD as a manager.  But it doesn’t have to be like that……

This blog post was inspired by Sarah Williams and Lis Geake and their comments on my last posting about ‘yes but…’

Lis’s very precise take on feedback (I’m choosing my words carefully here as I know she’ll be checking this!) “It would be a lot easier to avoid ‘yes but’ if people giving praise focused on specifics. “You did great work” isn’t half as much use as “The errors you corrected in my presentation have saved me a lot of time and saved my blushes”. It’s much harder to say ‘but’ after specific praise, which pops up in childcare books but is just as worth doing for adults. Should I be bold and share this thought on Caroline’s blog? Maybe, but…”

Apart from being making me laugh, she’s right of course!specific feedback

Some key tips for giving feedback:

  • be sincere – if people detect you don’t mean it they will lose trust in you
  • know why you are giving it – do you genuinely intend it to help them improve their performance or boost their morale, or just to cover your back?
  • adopt the ‘Dutch’ belief about feedback – how can someone act on something if they don’t know about it?  rather than the British approach that it’s either  i) a cruel and heartless thing to do and should only be used in extremis (if negative) or  ii) a very unBritish expression of emotion and they should just know I think it’s good (when positive)
  • a useful formula for being specific is ‘AID’ – what was the ACTION, what was the IMPACT, what could they DO more of/do differently or DEVELOP

What are your top tips for effective feedback? share your thoughts here or on my Facebook page: CarolineTalbottLtd Facebook

If you haven’t already signed up to be notified of new posts go to ‘Email Subscription’ at the top right of the page.

© andrewgenn – Fotolia.com

  1. July 6, 2012 at 10:15

    Reblogged this on Careersafter40 and commented:
    Today’s post is written by my special guest Caroline Talbott.

  2. Mike Hughes
    July 9, 2012 at 15:11

    Hi Caroline, Thanks for another good blog post (that’s the ‘British’ feedback out of the way!). In particular I like the succinct, specific nature of what you write about and the tips you provide.
    As for my top tip, I believe that feedback is most effective when it is both informative and motivating. How have I done?

    • July 9, 2012 at 15:26

      Thank you Mike, great to hear from you! That is certainly motivating and informative and I particularly enjoyed the humour – made me smile, which is just what I needed on a wet, cold summer afternoon while dealing with my finances, which always drains my energy. So it also has another essential feature – timely!

  1. August 30, 2012 at 09:14

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: